Skip to content
Holding Companyby ASWATAX
Talk to us

Setting up a holding company · Three trading companies

A holding company above three trading companies owned by a couple

How we inserted a holding company above three separately run companies owned by a couple, by share-for-share exchange with HMRC clearance, ready for acquisitions.

At a glance

  • Client: a couple who own three separately run companies, in varying proportions, with a 5% minority shareholder in one of them
  • Route: a new holding company acquired all of two companies and 95% of the third, by share-for-share exchange
  • Preparation: each company's share capital raised to 100 shares and reclassified, so each shareholder kept the same rights
  • HMRC: clearance applied for under section 138 TCGA 1992, section 701 ITA 2007 and section 748 CTA 2010, and granted
  • Tax points: no capital gains tax on the exchange; stamp duty payable on the 95% company because the shareholdings could not mirror each other

The client

Our client operated three separate companies, each carrying out a distinct commercial function. The businesses had grown independently, but had been run in a coordinated way for several years. The ownership was split between spouses in varying proportions. In one of the companies there was a minority shareholder with 5%.

Since the pandemic, the companies had operated one payroll, with intercompany invoicing used to allocate work done. That was adopted out of necessity, but over time it created inefficiencies. One company effectively ran payroll and invoiced the others, which skewed turnover figures and made it difficult to present a clear financial picture.

The challenge

  • The structure no longer matched how the businesses were run. A more formal arrangement was needed.
  • Mixed trading. One company had seen a drop in online sales, another had strong sales and planned a larger showroom, and a third faced suppliers beginning to compete directly and had invested in new tooling. The overall outlook was positive.
  • Acquisitions. The shareholder was exploring the purchase of a neighbouring business, which had been expected to complete before the restructuring but was delayed on the seller's side. Other owners in the sector were considering retirement. The existing structure made it hard to bring new companies in cleanly or to protect the existing ones from risk.
  • Long-term planning. The shareholder wanted to protect the trading companies, spread risk by buying or starting other companies, reinvest profits into new ventures and support a future transfer to family.

What we did

  • Standardised the share capital. The companies had been incorporated at different times with different numbers of shares. Each increased its share capital to 100 shares, then the shares were reclassified into separate classes to reflect the existing ownership proportions.
  • Formed the holding company. It was set up solely to become the parent of the group, and acquired all the shares in Company A, all the shares in Company B and 95% of Company C. The consideration was new shares in the holding company with the same rights as the shares previously held. Because it was a share-for-share exchange, no capital gains tax arose and the base cost carried over.
  • Dealt with the minority shareholder. Company C had a minority shareholder, so the holding company shareholdings could not mirror the original structure, and full stamp duty relief was not available for that part. Stamp duty was payable on the value of the shares transferred, fixed as at the date of the transaction.
  • Insisted on reliable accounts. The accounts for Company C contained errors and key balances did not reconcile. We told the client immediately and asked for corrected accounts before valuing the shares. It caused a delay, but protected the client from potential penalties.
  • Applied for HMRC clearance under section 138 TCGA 1992, section 701 ITA 2007 and section 748 CTA 2010. HMRC confirmed the restructure was for genuine commercial reasons and not for tax avoidance.
  • Submitted the transfers for stamp duty adjudication. HMRC issued an authentication code confirming the stamp duty position. Because the statutory records were in good order, we could collate the supporting documents promptly.

The outcome

  • One holding company above all three trading companies, with a single point of oversight and a clear hierarchy.
  • No capital gains tax on the exchange, and each shareholder keeping the same economic and voting rights.
  • HMRC clearance granted, and the stamp duty position confirmed through adjudication.
  • A platform for future acquisitions, better protection of assets, improved tax planning opportunities and a more coherent framework for long-term growth.

What it shows

A restructure is only as sound as the figures behind it. Where one company has a minority shareholder, stamp duty can arise on that company even though the rest of the exchange is relieved, and the value must be supported by accurate accounts. Getting that right before the exchange is what lets the clearance and the adjudication run smoothly.

BEFOREShareholdersown the shares directly100%TradeCo Ltdtrading companyProfits, cash, property and riskall sit in one companyAFTERShareholderssame people, same proportions100%HoldCo Ltdnew holding companyNEW100%TradeCo Ltdunchanged: same tradeShare-for-share exchange: CGT relief (s135)and stamp duty relief (s77) if conditions are met
  1. 1Form the new holding company, with the same shareholders and share structure as the trading company.
  2. 2Apply to HMRC for clearance under s138 TCGA 1992 and s701 ITA 2007, before any shares are issued.
  3. 3Exchange the shares, then send the stock transfer form to HMRC to claim stamp duty relief under s77 FA 1986.
Inserting a holding company. The shareholders swap their shares in the trading company for new shares in a holding company. They end up owning the same business in the same proportions, one level up. With the right conditions met, and HMRC clearance obtained first, there is no capital gains tax and no stamp duty on the exchange. Holding company Trading company

FAQs

Frequently asked questions

Why did the shareholders need a holding company above three companies they already ran together?

The businesses had been run in a coordinated way for several years, with one payroll and intercompany invoicing, but the legal structure did not reflect that. One company ran payroll and invoiced the others, which skewed turnover figures and made it hard to present a clear financial picture. A holding company gave a single point of oversight and a clear hierarchy.

How does a holding company help with acquisitions?

The shareholder had been exploring the purchase of a neighbouring business, and had looked at other acquisitions as owners in the sector considered retirement. The existing structure made it hard to bring new companies in cleanly or to protect the existing ones from risk. With a holding company, new businesses can be added beneath it, using the strength of the group.

Why did each company's share capital need to be standardised first?

The companies had been incorporated at different times with different numbers of shares, which would have made the share-for-share exchange needlessly complicated. Each company increased its share capital to 100 shares. The shares were then reclassified into separate classes to reflect the existing ownership proportions, so each shareholder kept the same economic and voting rights.

Was there capital gains tax on the exchange?

No. The exchange was structured as a share-for-share exchange, so no capital gains tax was triggered. The shareholders' base cost in their original shares transferred to their new shares in the holding company.

Why was full stamp duty relief not available for one of the companies?

One of the companies had a minority shareholder holding 5%, so the holding company acquired 95% of it. That meant the shareholdings in the holding company could not be a perfect mirror image of the original structure. Stamp duty was therefore payable on the value of the shares transferred for that company, and that value had to be fixed as at the exact date of the transaction.

What happened when the company's accounts contained errors?

Stamp duty is calculated on market value, and HMRC expects valuations to be supported by accurate financial information. When the accounts for that company arrived, key balances did not reconcile, so we could not value the shares. We told the client at once and asked for corrected accounts. This caused a delay, but it protected the client from potential penalties and made sure the transaction could withstand HMRC scrutiny.

Which HMRC clearance was applied for?

We submitted a clearance application under section 138 TCGA 1992, section 701 ITA 2007 and section 748 CTA 2010. HMRC confirmed the restructure was being undertaken for genuine commercial reasons and not for tax avoidance. The exchange then went ahead.

What is stamp duty adjudication?

After the restructure, we submitted the transfer instruments to HMRC for adjudication, and HMRC then issued an authentication code confirming the stamp duty position. The process was lengthy and needed a fair amount of supporting documentation. Because the statutory records were in good order and updated as the transaction progressed, we were able to collate the documents promptly.

What can the shareholder now do that they could not before?

The shareholder can add new companies beneath the holding company, protect the trading companies from one another's risk, reinvest profits from the existing companies into new ventures and plan a future transfer to family. The group now has one clear parent company.

Free guide

The UK business owner's complete guide to holding companies

Why owner-managers set up holding companies, how the share-for-share exchange and HMRC clearances work, protecting cash and property, selling under SSE or BADR, and passing the business on.

The UK business owner's complete guide to holding companies

Talk to us before you buy, sell or restructure.

The right group structure protects what you've built and keeps your options open. A free first call with a Chartered Tax Adviser, and a reply the same working day.

Or write to holdingcompany@aswatax.co.uk

Chartered Tax Adviser
Message us on WhatsApp (opens in a new tab)